In Alberta, as across the world, healthcare workers have been on the frontlines of the COVID-19 pandemic, navigating unprecedented challenges and experiencing both physical and emotional tolls. While the pandemic has impacted everyone’s mental health, it is healthcare professionals, especially nurses, who have faced some of the most intense pressures. In particular, nurses have been vulnerable to vicarious trauma—the emotional and psychological toll of caring for patients who have experienced significant trauma, such as severe illness or death due to COVID-19.

A recent study analyzing the mental health of healthcare workers in Canada, with a focus on nurses, provides critical insights into how the pandemic has affected their well-being. This blog post explores these findings, emphasizing the importance of treatment options and the need for presumptive legislation to better support frontline workers like nurses and doctors.

Understanding Vicarious Trauma and Its Impact

Vicarious trauma, often referred to as compassion fatigue, occurs when individuals, through continuous empathic engagement with others’ trauma, experience emotional distress. For healthcare workers, especially those in high-stress environments like ICUs, emergency departments, and COVID-19 wards, the psychological impact of witnessing suffering and death can accumulate over time, leading to significant mental health challenges.

Throughout the pandemic, many healthcare workers have found themselves overwhelmed by the emotional toll of seeing patients struggle with severe illness or pass away. Nurses, in particular, are often the ones who spend the most time with patients, providing direct care and comfort. As a result, they may be more susceptible to the psychological effects of vicarious trauma. The study we’ll discuss shows how this trauma, alongside general burnout, has worsened the mental health of nurses, particularly when compared to their pre-pandemic state.

The Study’s Insights: A Comparative Look at Healthcare Workers’ Mental Health

The study, based on data from Statistics Canada’s crowdsourcing initiative, provides a comprehensive look at the mental health of healthcare workers during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. By analyzing responses from over 12,000 healthcare professionals, the study found that nurses and doctors, compared to allied healthcare workers, reported significantly poorer mental health outcomes.

While doctors reported an increase in mental stress during the pandemic, nurses, unfortunately, reported no improvement in their mental health compared to pre-COVID times. Mental health for many nurses remained poor, indicating that while the pandemic added an additional layer of trauma, many nurses had been struggling with stress even before the pandemic began.

The findings were striking: nurses were significantly more likely than allied healthcare workers to report “poor” mental health during the pandemic. This data aligns with what many healthcare professionals have known anecdotally—nurses have faced the most significant emotional burden during the pandemic.

The Importance of Treatment: Addressing the Mental Health Crisis

The mental health crisis among healthcare workers cannot be overstated. While the physical risks of the pandemic were visible, the emotional toll on workers like nurses has often gone unnoticed. The need for comprehensive mental health support is critical, both in the short and long term.

Effective treatment options are necessary to address vicarious trauma and general burnout. These might include:

• Stress reduction programs that teach mindfulness, relaxation techniques, and coping strategies to help healthcare workers manage the emotional toll of their work.
• Counseling services that offer both individual and group therapy to help workers process the trauma they’ve witnessed.
• Peer support networks, where nurses and other healthcare workers can share their experiences and offer mutual support.

Presumptive Legislation: Protecting Those Who Protect Us

While individual treatment is essential, there is also a pressing need for presumptive legislation to better protect healthcare workers from the long-term effects of trauma. Presumptive legislation allows workers who have been exposed to specific risks—like vicarious trauma in healthcare settings—to access workers’ compensation benefits more easily.

Currently, workers’ compensation laws in Alberta do not automatically recognize psychological injuries such as vicarious trauma, making it harder for healthcare workers to receive compensation for mental health conditions related to their work. This gap in coverage creates additional stress for workers already dealing with burnout and emotional exhaustion.

Presumptive legislation could change this by formally recognizing the mental health risks of frontline workers and providing them with the support they need. By acknowledging the unique psychological toll that comes with healthcare work, this legislation would offer critical protection and ensure that healthcare workers receive the mental health resources and financial support they deserve.

Conclusion:

As we look to the future, it is clear that healthcare workers, particularly nurses, need both immediate mental health interventions and long-term legislative protections. The COVID-19 pandemic may be over, but its effects on healthcare workers will be felt for years to come.

Now, more than ever, we must prioritize the mental health of healthcare professionals. Supporting them through treatment programs, providing counseling, and enacting presumptive legislation will not only help alleviate their stress and trauma but will also improve patient care and reduce turnover rates.

Healthcare workers put their lives on the line every day to care for others. It’s time we show them the same level of care and commitment.

---

Call to Action: If you are a healthcare worker experiencing mental health challenges, or if you are someone who wants to support them, consider advocating for presumptive legislation and promoting mental health resources. It’s time for us to ensure that those who dedicate their lives to caring for others are supported with the care they need.

---

Resource:

Tiagi R. The impact of COVID-19 on relative health outcomes among healthcare workers in Canada. Healthcare Manage Forum. 2022 Nov;35(6):349-355. doi: 10.1177/08404704221112288. Epub 2022 Jul 13. PMID: 35830293; PMCID: PMC9280119. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9280119/